For MP, the best in the series was Balance of Power for XvT because you could co-op an entire campaign. I remember playing that with my best friend in college, with me flying squadron leader on the A-wings and him flying escort in the X-wings. I'd often end up covering for him and just doing crazy close-up fly-bys of enemy ships at high speed to help buy him time to get out and get whatever convoy we were protecting out of the system.
What I really always wanted to do, though, was to build an entire elaborate campaign where the game was basically "DMed" such that what happened during the mission would impact the next mission. So, if you fail the mission....you just fail the mission. No replays, and you live with the consequences.
Gods below, I miss that. I did much the same, far too briefly back in the '90s. That's where I got my favorite callsign, that I still paint on certain of my Imperial fighter model kits.
As for as on-topic...? As so many others have said, there are too many that are too amazing across so many size/capability ranges. I love many that others have mentioned, such as the
Yamato, but if we're talking
favorite-favorites...
"Fighter"-sized
The original BSG Viper
Galaxy Rangers Interceptor
Several from Star Wars... I love the TIE Avenger
Royal Guard TIE Interceptor
TIE Phantom
The Mandalorian
Gauntlet fighter
...and the venerable Y-Wing
No list of mine would be complete without the Gunstar from The Last Starfighter
Moving up a size class to things you can move around in...
Freighters and Frigates and Corvettes, oh my!
Back to Star Wars for the
Charger-class Frigate
and the Republic
Nu-class attack shuttle (an updated evolution of which is what I wish had been the First Order landing craft in The Force Awakens)
The
Sulaco
The
Starjammer
And, to keep things at least
slightly manageable, on to
Capital Ships
I'll start with about the most capital of capital ships, the Command Ship
Eclipse
From Uchuu Senkan Yamato, the EDF flagship
Andromeda
The
Cygnus
And I'll finish with the one that needs no introduction...
There are many more that I love, including various
Enterprises and other Trek ships, but these top my lists.
--Jonah