Thank you for the additional info Chris...one more question (sorry) I actually have a bottle of Polly Scale Boxcar Red (which is the exact same color as the Floquil Boxcar Red) but it is very much a 'brownish' red compared to the more 'maroonish' color seen on the falcon...it does not seem to be the right red color, perhaps it is the Floquil Caboose Red (see images below)
Polly Scale Boxcar Red / Floquil Boxcar Red
View attachment 477265View attachment 477266
Floquil Caboose Red
View attachment 477264
LrdSatyr8, thank you for that information as well...I am looking into those paints...but some of the colors seem to be missing on that site, there is no red or dark gray available?
imurme
Here's a chip chart I put together to test some various options for replicating the original Floquil enamels.
View attachment 477285
This test was for colors used on the AT-AT, but the differences will show that you need to be careful trusting anything right out of the bottle. I have all the original Floquil paints for the Falcon, and when I get a moment I plan to spray a chip chart so I can compare them to what's available now. I'll either mix my own acrylic colors with Tamiya paints or buy the ones LrdSatyr8 recommends.
MicroScale also has the following handy chart on their website for matching the original Floquil colors:
https://www.microscale.com/Floquil Color Chart.pdf
I haven't tested any of these but it's worth a look.
You can't necessarily trust the Polly Scale versions of the Floquil colors. I tested Polly Scale Aged Concrete, and Reefer Gray against the Floquil paints and the acrylics were very different from the original enamels.
Any chance you could post up a comparison between the Floquil and Pollyscale Grime along with the other gray and red colours?
I managed to get both the Floquil and PolyScale Reefer Yellow. The PS yellow is very close but brighter. The Floquil is deeper.
I think in all honesty though even if you have the exact Floquil paints it wll still be hard to get an exact match as all these colours had primer underneath and overspary of other colours on top of them. So depending on the density of the paint overtop the undercoat and the amount of overspray on any particular spot trying to match exactly will be difficult and will always require some degree of subjectivity.
OK, thanks.
I wonder what they used for reference, or how accurate they are?
I managed to get both the Floquil and PolyScale Reefer Yellow. The PS yellow is very close but brighter. The Floquil is deeper.
It sure would help to see an image (photo) comparison between the two versions of the Floquil & PollyScale Reefer Yellow...I went to my local train shop, but all they had was the Model Master versions, I picked up the one labeled as Reefer Yellow but it seems VERY yellow...is that what the Floquil looks like?
You're welcome, imurme. I spent a *lot* of time at the good hobby shop in town, comparing MM, Floquil, PolyScale and whatever else he had to find the closest matches. I still have one more shop to check out next week. Hoping to find a better replacement for the MM Flat Concrete that I purchased.
After much experimenting I decided to keep it simple and use 2 parts Tamiya White and 1 part Tamiya deck tan as the base color. It's a great earthy hue, and after weathering with oils it warms up and darkens in a way that has that distinct falcon look to my eye.
Thanks for taking the time to post. I will mix up a sample using your suggestion. I was originally thinking I would achieve the slight green tint by doing an oil wash during the weathering stage. Adding to the base color does seem a more straight forward way to go.CR that is a good base color mix (2 parts Tamiya XF2 Flat White and 1 part Tamiya XF55 Deck Tan)...If you want to bring it a little closer to the Grime color try adding a drop or two of Tamiya XF12 J.N. Grey (maybe 9 parts Tamiya XF2 Flat White and 6 parts Tamiya XF55 Deck Tan with 1 - 2 parts Tamiya XF12 J.N. Grey)...this adds a bit of green to the mix, bringing it closer to the grime color used on the falcon...just thought I would mention it