cboath
Master Member
Re: Star Wars Episode VII
Just a thought, but why would create a desert set for star wars and have it not be tatooine? True, many planets could have deserts on them (and multiples per planet at that), it kind of diverges from what we've seen in 6 flicks...
Naboo - lush and green
Tat - desert
Coruscant - city planet
Geonosis - not so much desert (it seemed) as desolate/caves/mesa's
Kamino - all water
Mustafar - lava planet
Kashyyk - jungle planet
(whatever planet grevious was on - kind of an asteroid with a city in a giant hole)
Alderaan - apparently all fine type forests from the whole 15 seconds we see of it
Yavin 4 - jungle
Hoth - ice planet
Endor - redwood forest planet
Short of Kashyyk/Yavin/Endor everything has been very different. You could argue the ruins set Yavin apart as well. Endor/Kashyyk look pretty similar, but combined probably don't net 10 minutes of screen time - maybe 5 at best.
Short of a 'gotcha' there doesn't seem to be much logical reason to have a desert locale if not tatooine. Doesn't mean it could be something else, but logic suggests otherwise. I'd say the longer they shoot there the better the odds it's tatoine. Seems to be an extreme locale, though, if it's just for 5 minutes of screen time.
Just a thought, but why would create a desert set for star wars and have it not be tatooine? True, many planets could have deserts on them (and multiples per planet at that), it kind of diverges from what we've seen in 6 flicks...
Naboo - lush and green
Tat - desert
Coruscant - city planet
Geonosis - not so much desert (it seemed) as desolate/caves/mesa's
Kamino - all water
Mustafar - lava planet
Kashyyk - jungle planet
(whatever planet grevious was on - kind of an asteroid with a city in a giant hole)
Alderaan - apparently all fine type forests from the whole 15 seconds we see of it
Yavin 4 - jungle
Hoth - ice planet
Endor - redwood forest planet
Short of Kashyyk/Yavin/Endor everything has been very different. You could argue the ruins set Yavin apart as well. Endor/Kashyyk look pretty similar, but combined probably don't net 10 minutes of screen time - maybe 5 at best.
Short of a 'gotcha' there doesn't seem to be much logical reason to have a desert locale if not tatooine. Doesn't mean it could be something else, but logic suggests otherwise. I'd say the longer they shoot there the better the odds it's tatoine. Seems to be an extreme locale, though, if it's just for 5 minutes of screen time.