greatwazoo42
Master Member
Re: Yale and ERA Tardis Key Research (Info for the 2005-present keys)
Impressive research as always!
Impressive research as always!
Your question had me further scrutinizing the keys. Here's what I came up with on that note:
A comparative tracing of the three:
View attachment 100341
The Perception Filter keys match the Father's Day key as well.
Please note that the above drawings are in no way accurate. I did a quick and dirty job. Please don't go through the trouble of trying to cut keys based on them.
I'm pretty sure it's not an ERA as I remember a few years ago it being identified on another forum - the TARDIS builders I think - but that forum has had so many versions and hosts that I can't find the thread. Could have been here even though. I think the key said access or axess or something like that, though I can't be sure till I find that thread or someone who remembers it. But they have used other brands as well.
EDIT: Here is it, it's axxess+ The key in this pic is too short but they do offer the ER1 style key, they just post draws rather than this site which had a real pic. During my search I found other brands such as ilco, JMA and NWKS which all have the proper look - though only the axxess+ looks like the blink key. NWKS looks like a great match for the Water of Mars still above though.
And Blink again to compare the logo (remember the key above is too short and a different blank code - which is why the logo is perfectly round and not flat on the bottom, that flat part is part of the ER1 style - but they do make the ER1 keys, just can't find a real pic)
In fact, I contacted a few companied in the UK to make copies of my ERA keys so that I had some to hand out as gifts, I was given a few different brans alternatives which all had the same look with the round top and one shoulder but ERA Security had actually agreed to help me out so I went with them in the end to get my copies made.
EDIT: The first company I was speaking with in the UK said they could make blanks for me out of one called Silca brand and they gave me this link to their site: NW Keys Ltd - Silca ER1 Era cylinder key I know the picture here looks oval and not round but the assured me it was a round top not oval. That said, in the end I did go with ERA Security as they offered me the real key - which I like because I know they were used in the show and I love that they say "era" since the show is based on Time Travel - and because they actually came through. No disrespect to those at nwkeys but they said they would get back to me on a quote and then disapeared.
Yeah I actually wasn't too happy when I got it but thankfully I had the real ones that I bought prior with a cylinder of their own.
I had thought this as well, but a friend of mine seemed to think it would be easy to sand and buff the chrome knob no problem. He does that sort of stuff from time to time. But I am not ruling it out myself.
Here's a shot from SJA as well. And while they could have CGI'd it too, it is less likely given their budget.
Did she? Nice. I don't have a deviant art myself but I keep being asked to get one. Yeah I gave that to her in February at Katsucon. I like your D Shackle as it does have a good match, but the thing I like about mine is that it's self locking so that the thing won't unscrew in her pocket. That said, I'd be happy to have the ebay seller from you as I'd like to compare in person. And I counted about the same as you or near enough, 38 or 39 small links and two large ones, so either 40 or 41 in the end, I'd have to count my chain again to confirm exactly as I did this back in January though. I blew up the publicity sill of her in photoshop counted, made the chain, then took pics to super impose over hers for good measure.
I figured for the sake of archiving (and because i am bored here today) it couldn't hurt to post the pics of the Doctor and Companion keys from the New Series. Let me know if I missed anyone out. Companions who did not have their own key in the New Series were:
Adam Mitchell (the companion who couldn't)
Mickey Smith
Sarah Jane Smith (yeah, I'm counting her because she rocked!)
Amy Pond
Rory Williams
River Song (seems she didn't need one)
First the Doctor's Key, as stated above he just left it natural, no chain or twine etc.
Eccleston: Not sanded in this pic but could have been in part of Series 1
Tennant: From what I can remember it's always been Sanded for Tennant. However if a pic of a nonsanded key can be seen in use by him, let me know and I'll update this.
Smith: And sanded again for Smith
Next, the companions:
Rose Tyler: Not sanded here in Aliens of London (when she gets a key) but can be seen sanded in The Long Game (which can be seen in an above post). It is a very specific key chain here, both Straker and I have replicated this and would be happy to give pointers to anyone who would like to as well, I'm sure.
Captain Jack Harkness: The Time we can see it it is sanded in Sound of Drums.
In Bad Wolf he had the key loose in his pocket with no chain or ring. Impossible to get a good screencap as they don't do a close up of it.
Then in Sound of Drums he had it on his key ring with lots of other keys. - This is the best cap I could get of his keys.Of course you can see his along with Martha and the Doctor's keys being made into Perception Filters but I was more trying to show his key chain)
Martha Jones: I know it's hard to tell from this pic but when Martha is given the key in 42 it appears to be unsanded - Look at the hole where the chain goes through - Now it could just be light reflection but the way it's reflecting around the hole and the rim of the key looks to be in the same pattern as the non-logo side of the ERA key. However if it is unsaded then it can't be an ERA key as the side shown would be the logo side. Later in Sound of Drums it is easy to see that it is sanded.
Marth's key is just on a ball chain, no ring. Although it seems she wasn't overly fond of the chain as she doesn't have it on the key in The Sound of Drums.
Sally Sparrow: Not really a companion but she had her own key. Her key was not sanded in the beginning of Blink - and also appears to not be an ERA key - but when she uses it in the TARDIS door the key becomes a sanded one (Which can be seen in one of the above posts)
Donna Noble: Donna's key is sanded and has no chain or ring or anything. The companion's keys got less and less fancy as he gave them out.
That's all that I have. Again if I've left someone out, let me know. I do know that Sarah and Jo both nearly brought a TARDIS key to life in Death of the Doctor but I did not cap that yet either, not sure if it is needed.
Anyway, thanks for putting up with my boredom.
Also found this interesting from one of the DW card games:
Looks to be an ERA key with wear at first but if that is the case then the picture is either flipped on the card or it's one of the non-ERA keys as the side shown is the logo side of a standard ERA key. Of course it could not even be a screen used key but it is interesting that it matches Martha's 42 key in this way.
Interesting. I looked up what Axxess key would fit but it's number 71 and the picture I found was the wrong shaped head. Makes me wonder if that key in Blink was a different key JUST for that shot. I can imagine them being on the set, realizing they needed a Tardis key but didn't have one so they just used the closest match from some grips own key ring XD Still, that does indeed look like the right match. What Axxess key number is it supposed to be? Only few that match for me is 71 or 111. 71 for the channels and 111 for how it looks.
I think that would only work if the lock wasn't chrome but brushed stainless. Chrome is a plating and if you sand through it it's rather hard to fix without paying to have it chromed again. Digitally painting it out is easier I think.
Not the same shot. It looks like some of this was used in that previous digital shot but this is real. he light on the outer ring is natural and there's no blue in the keyway. There's also a shadow under the lock on the blue of the box here that wasn't in the other. This is a much better look at the door lock than the other picture.
Well if you're curious the D shackle I used is great once tightened up. I used a pair of smooth jaw pliers to give it an extra quarter turn but if you're interested: CHAIN D RIGGING SHACKLE FOR BOAT 5/32´´ check it out. The seller originally listed it as 5/8" but then went to 5/32" or 4mm which is the threaded shaft diameter. Still the same one I bought though.
After trying 40 I kinda liked mine a bit longer XD It may not be accurate but I liked how 55 felt in my hand XD
Good stuff. I would say though that the picture for Sally Sparrows key there looks like an ERA in that shot...well, that particular shot. They appear to have used a few keys for that one for some reason XD
Also, I REALLY wouldn't use that card game for reference material of any sort. They aren't very accurate at all. This was THEIR chipped Tardis key :
...yikes! Not a surprise when you see so many inaccurate keys out there XD
Unfortunately I still have not found the old thread that showed the correct key and info, but I found the brand. I know that Yale locks are the same though, they either have the key we have or a key with a totally different head, but they both work in the same lock, so axxess+ may be no different.
I'll be able to tell you when he gets his lock in his hands. The other thing is they would have only needed to do it to one lock, since you only ever see it on the interior doors. But like I said, my first reaction was CGI as well.
Yeah this shot looked the real deal to me and really SJA was like the step child of the shows, they had the lowest budget and in this story more of that was used on other special effects. But again, CGI can't really be ruled out until someone gets good quality pics of the real box (not the BBC promo box though).
Cool thanks. I am even more curious now as mine is a 5/32, so I really want to do a size comparison.
Sometimes with props it is best to go with an idealized version, but I like my key matching hers and certainly for cons it looks great when my girlfriends holds it in the same way as that promo shot of Rose.
In any given episode where we see the key we could be seeing multiple versions depending on which box they use or how they want it to look in show, but in the same scene Sally finds her key you see both sides of the key and since they would have filmed those over the same few days it is likely that they could have used the same key on set, however if these shots were pickups or second unit they could have changed the key. But I do believe the back of the ERA key has been seen on other keys. I really wish I could find that old thread, I've been looking like madness. Here is both sides of Sally's key in that shot.
EDIT: Actually, looking at the two pics together (and for now to differentiate them I'll call them axxess and ERA) the axxess key looks to be showing the same side as the ERA (the shoulder/bump is on the same side). So that really means they did not use the same key in this scene.
True. Too bad it would be VERY hard to just wear off the chrome in the head in the recessed parts like that picture XPYeah I had my doubts there really. But it does show how an ERA might actually wear so that's something at least.
Well in an interesting day I did some digging on AXXESS and apparently the 71 key fits the Yale Y-1 and ERA key but there's some problems. One is that if you go to Home Depot or Lowes the ERA key won't fit into the stupid cartridge they use to identify the keys so it will seem like no key they have matches it. .... A: Axxess changed the look of their key or B: the UK versions of this key are different than the US versions.
Well when I did the whole, "hold it up to the screen" comparison test it matched up pretty well. One thing I liked about it was the little round stopper thing that keeps the rod from going too far into the shackle. It just looks nice. I think you'll be pleased with it when you have it in hand.
Agreed. For myself i like the extra length but the chain for these is so inexpensive I can afford to have more than one at both accurate and idealized length.
True. Too bad it would be VERY hard to just wear off the chrome in the head in the recessed parts like that picture XP
So update guys. I don't think they key used in Blink was an AXXESS after all. I think it was a JMA. Wanna see?
Check
This
Out:
Waffle pattern on the correct side, single bumper, rectangular window for logo, and the correct straight section similar to the ERA key!
It's a JMA YA41D 5 pin key. Y1 / 999 YALE JMA KEY BLANK
WHO DA MAN!
This is why I ended up going to the UK and having ERA Security make my spare keys for me. No place here that I went to could match the key. Despite the fact that I have a key from here that fits the ERA lock perfectly. I want to try more mom and pop shops next and then a lock smith as I would like some sanded keys.
And I agree, the axxess key was probably a stand in, I'm happy to have an ERA key for her's in my collection. I don't really like the axxess key look at all.
I ordered a couple to try them out for sure. So thanks for sharing. The real test will be in the ring comes undone with my girlfriend's habits of caring it around with her.
Very true. I have made four of these so far. I have gifted a few of my keys. Such a subtle and tiny little prop that gets so much appreciation.
And at the same time, I would be fixated on the fact that it's not silver anymore. Ah... OCD fandom.
Very nice work sir! Every site I found with a JMA key just showed a drawing and not the real key. I'd say that's a spot on match.
Any clue what it is made out of? Could these be sanded correctly?
Try a True Value or any old lock smith. That's where I get mine done. Free too because I supply them the blanks.
Oddly enough I kinda dig it. XD
The extra detail with the shackle helps a bit. Not a detail most people ever notice. I had to explain to people several times the reason they used it. It's hard to figure unless you know the nautical theme they were originally going for in 2005. U Boat Jacket, the coral inside the Tardis, the D-shackle, all nautical items XD
I'm going to order five at least, ten if possible IF any of you guys want one but I want a few to experiment with for myself but if the seller is OK with it I will ask him if he would be willing to sell the blanks and if so I will let him know he will get a small influx of buyers for those blanks.
Well if we can identify a good match for the ERA key that can be sanded and still be silver then yeah, I'll do the same with the blanks. True Value I haven't thought of, I'll have to see if any still exist around here.
Of course you mean the JMA key now Like I said above, if I can get good blanks and have someone here cut them like you suggested, I'd probably get a JMA just for good measure, but at the same time, I want to have some restraint
Exactly, I've seen them sold on ebay for prices that always gave me a good laugh (saw you deviant art by the way) both at price and what they called "screen accurate". I mean the key was always clearly seen in Aliens of London, it was never in doubt to me what it was. I just hadn't tried to make the key all these years because I didn't own any. Then one day I said "why not?" so I researched and bought some. Like you said, it's such a cheap and easy thing to make. But out of all the new series keys it is the most stylistic.
Well if you are already getting them then yeah I would take one. And I would be interested in a blank as well (there goes the self restraint) so I can have one cut to match my lock. Thanks for the offer on the cut key and for keeping us posted on the seller and blanks.
The only thing with the key in the pic is that it does look a bit long. Not sure if that is a trick of the photography or not though.
The question is are the JMA keys chromed or can they be sanded to look like a blank brandless key? Good finds though for sure, for those wanting to add one of the Blink Keys to their collection.
Oh I hadn't noticed that you had World War 3 listed to be honest, but yeah it's Aliens of London. Though the New Series seems way better at showing us the key than the classic.
Now I just need to find a local place that can cut these blanks when we get them. I want to Lowes, Home Depot, Ace Hardware and about three smaller places that my GPS found me. No one carried a match for the key. I'll step up my search now though, especially since I want to find a blank that can be sanded.
The question is are the JMA keys chromed or can they be sanded to look like a blank brandless key? Good finds though for sure, for those wanting to add one of the Blink Keys to their collection. *SNIP!*