Art Andrews said:
For me, the new costume makes Superman look more like what I think of him as, an alien! The old costume looks just like, well, a costume!
I agree that compared to the old costume, the new is dark, but by itself, I don't think it is too dark or menacing.
One thing that I really like about the new costume that I don't think we see in the old is that Superman looks powerful and I really think that is important. The comics have almost always gotten this right, but ALL of the movies have fallen down in this area. This is the first time Superman looks like he might be the strongest man in the world.
I understand the power of nostalgia, but when I look at the Reeves costume compared to the Man of Steel costume, the Reeves costume is painfully cheesy and outdated. Did they need to go with the full on chainmail look? No, but to me, the Man of Steel costume is one I can get behind a whole lot more than I can the Reeves costume.
Oh, and the cape IS indeed amazing on the new costume!