The Abbyshot jacket looks pretty bad. Definitely looks off for some reason. The vertical lines don't seem dark enough. Plus the red lines don't look right. Steve Ricks posted a reference image of the actual fabric on his blog. The red lines should be spaced at 35mm-40mm-35mm-40mm (and so on) apart from each other but the Abbyshot jacket red lines look like they're all evenly spaced out. Just doesn't look all that good to me.
Link to that ref picture article (plus it's a great blog to read in general):
Making My 11th Doctor Costume: Season Six Tweed jacket –making the body
Loving the new green jacket, it looks great on Matt. Hoping it sticks around.